ML System Design Document Review Checklist
Problem Definition
- Clear problem statement with measurable objectives
- Well-defined scope and constraints
- Identified stakeholders and their requirements
- Justified business value and impact
- Analyzed existing solutions and their limitations
- Assessed risks and failure modes
- Estimated costs of mistakes
- Defined success criteria
Metrics and Losses
- Defined business metrics
- Selected appropriate model metrics
- Justified loss functions
- Aligned metrics with business goals
- Considered trade-offs
- Defined evaluation strategy
- Set up measurement framework
- Planned A/B testing approach
Data Considerations
- Identified all data sources (internal/external)
- Assessed data quality and freshness
- Documented data pipeline architecture
- Addressed data privacy and security
- Considered data versioning strategy
- Evaluated data storage requirements
- Planned data labeling process
- Documented metadata usage
- Designed ETL pipeline
- Set up data quality checks
Validation Strategy
- Defined validation requirements
- Designed validation schema
- Prevented data leakage
- Planned update frequency
- Set up cross-validation strategy
- Considered temporal aspects
- Documented validation process
- Planned for data drift
Baseline Solutions
- Defined constant baselines
- Selected model baselines
- Identified feature baselines
- Set minimum performance requirements
- Planned comparison methodology
- Documented baseline results
- Set up improvement metrics
Error Analysis
- Planned learning curve analysis
- Set up residual analysis
- Identified edge cases
- Planned monitoring of failure modes
- Designed error tracking
- Set up performance analysis
- Planned improvement process
Training Pipeline
- Designed training architecture
- Selected appropriate tools
- Planned data preprocessing
- Set up experiment tracking
- Defined model versioning
- Planned resource allocation
- Documented training process
- Set up monitoring
Feature Engineering
- Defined feature selection criteria
- Listed initial features
- Planned feature tests
- Set up feature monitoring
- Documented feature dependencies
- Planned feature updates
- Considered computational constraints
Integration
- Designed API interfaces
- Planned release cycle
- Set up fallback strategies
- Defined operational procedures
- Planned monitoring and alerts
- Documented deployment process
- Set up incident response
- Defined SLAs
Documentation
- Clear writing and organization
- Technical details sufficient
- Diagrams and visualizations
- References and citations
- Glossary of terms
- Version history
- Maintenance procedures
- Update guidelines
System Architecture
- Detailed infrastructure requirements
- Scalability considerations
- Latency requirements
- Security measures
- Integration points
- Deployment strategy
Evaluation Strategy
- Clear success metrics
- A/B testing methodology
- Performance benchmarks
- Monitoring plan
- Alert thresholds
- Fallback strategies
Implementation Plan
- Realistic timeline
- Resource requirements
- Dependencies identified
- Risk assessment
- Mitigation strategies
- Success criteria
Maintenance & Operations
- Monitoring setup
- Update procedures
- Backup strategies
- Incident response plan
- SLAs defined
- Resource scaling plan